Indicating Instruments MCQ Quiz - Objective Question with Answer for Indicating Instruments - Download Free PDF

Explanation:

Moving-Iron Type Voltmeters and Ammeters

Definition: Moving-iron instruments are a class of electrical measuring devices used to measure voltages (voltmeters) and currents (ammeters). These instruments operate on the principle of electromagnetic force acting on a soft iron piece that moves when subjected to a magnetic field generated by the current or voltage.

Types: The two basic forms of moving-iron type instruments are:

• Attraction Type: In this type, a piece of soft iron is attracted towards a coil carrying the current or voltage, causing a deflection of the pointer on the calibrated scale. The amount of deflection is proportional to the current or voltage being measured.
• Repulsion Type: This type involves two pieces of soft iron placed near a coil. When current flows through the coil, both pieces of iron become magnetized with like polarities, resulting in a repulsive force between them. This force moves one of the iron pieces, which is connected to the pointer, causing a deflection on the scale proportional to the measured quantity.

Working Principle:

The working of moving-iron instruments is based on the magnetic field produced by the current or voltage in a coil. When a soft iron piece is placed in the vicinity of this magnetic field, it experiences either an attractive or repulsive force, depending on the type of moving-iron instrument. The resulting mechanical motion is converted into an angular deflection of the pointer over a calibrated scale.

Advantages:

• Moving-iron instruments can measure both AC and DC quantities, making them versatile for various applications.
• They are robust and can withstand overloads to a certain extent.
• They are relatively simple in construction and cost-effective.

Disadvantages:

• The scale of moving-iron instruments is non-linear, especially at lower ranges, making precise readings difficult in some cases.
• They are prone to errors caused by stray magnetic fields and temperature variations.
• Friction in the moving parts can affect the accuracy of the readings.

Applications:

• Used in power systems for monitoring current and voltage levels.
• Suitable for general-purpose measurements in laboratories and industries.
• Commonly employed in switchboards and distribution panels.

Correct Option Analysis:

The correct option is:

Option 2: Attraction type and Repulsion type

This option correctly identifies the two basic forms of moving-iron instruments. The attraction type involves the movement of a soft iron piece towards the coil due to magnetic attraction, while the repulsion type involves the repulsive force generated between two magnetized soft iron pieces. Both these types are widely used in the design of moving-iron voltmeters and ammeters, leveraging their simplicity and robustness for measuring electrical quantities.

Additional Information

To further understand the analysis, let’s evaluate the other options:

Option 1: Permanent magnet type and electrodynamic type

This option is incorrect because permanent magnet and electrodynamic types are not related to moving-iron instruments. Permanent magnet instruments (e.g., PMMC) use a permanent magnet and are primarily used for DC measurements. Electrodynamic instruments, on the other hand, use two coils (fixed and moving) and are suitable for AC and DC measurements, but they do not fall under the category of moving-iron instruments.

Option 3: Induction type and electrostatic type

This option is also incorrect. Induction type instruments work on the principle of electromagnetic induction and are typically used for measuring AC quantities, such as in energy meters. Electrostatic type instruments, on the other hand, measure voltage using the electrostatic force between two plates. Neither of these types is related to moving-iron instruments.

Option 4: Split-phase type and shaded-pole type

This option is incorrect as it refers to types of single-phase AC motors, not electrical measuring instruments. Split-phase and shaded-pole designs are used in small electric motors, such as those found in household fans or appliances, and have no connection to moving-iron voltmeters or ammeters.

Option 5:

There is no option 5 provided in the question, so it does not apply to the evaluation.

Conclusion:

The moving-iron type instruments are widely used for their versatility and simplicity. Understanding their two basic forms, attraction type and repulsion type, is crucial for their application in various electrical measurement tasks. While the other options describe different types of instruments or devices, they are not related to the moving-iron type voltmeters and ammeters. By leveraging the principles of electromagnetic force, these instruments provide reliable and robust solutions for measuring both AC and DC electrical quantities.

Explanation:

The Hot-Wire Ammeter

• A hot-wire ammeter is a device used to measure current in a circuit. It operates based on the principle of thermal expansion of a wire when heated by the electric current passing through it. The instrument is designed to measure the effective value of the current in both alternating current (AC) and direct current (DC) circuits.
• When an electric current flows through the wire in the hot-wire ammeter, the wire heats up due to the resistive power loss. The heat causes the wire to expand, and this expansion is mechanically translated into a movement, which is measured and displayed on a calibrated scale. Since the heating effect of the current is proportional to the square of the current and independent of its direction, the hot-wire ammeter can measure the effective value of AC or DC current without differentiation.

Advantages:

• Can measure both AC and DC currents without requiring separate instruments.
• Insensitive to the waveform of AC, as it measures the effective (RMS) value of the current.
• Simple construction and operation, relying only on the thermal expansion of the wire.

Disadvantages:

• Limited accuracy compared to other types of ammeters, such as moving-coil ammeters.
• Slow response time due to the thermal inertia of the wire.
• Susceptible to environmental factors such as temperature variations and vibrations.

Applications: Hot-wire ammeters are typically used in situations where measuring the effective value of current is more important than waveform analysis. They are suitable for measuring currents in AC circuits with complex waveforms and for DC circuits where simplicity and reliability are prioritized.

Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC)

Characteristics of the PMMC instrument

• PMMC is used to measure only DC or the average value of an electrical quantity. 
• The PMMC instrument has a linear or uniform scale, hence, the deflecting torque produced is directly proportional to the current.
• Either spring or gravity control can produce the controlling torque in PMMC instruments.
• For spring control: Tc ∝ θ, and for gravity control: Tc ∝ sin θ 
• In Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC), Electromagnetic damping is used to quickly settle the pointer without oscillation. It is achieved using eddy currents induced in a conducting coil or aluminum former moving in the field of a permanent magnet.

Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC)

Characteristics of the PMMC instrument

• PMMC is used to measure only DC or the average DC value of an electrical quantity. It cannot measure AC values.
• The PMMC instrument has a linear or uniform scale, hence, the deflecting torque produced is directly proportional to the current.
• The controlling torque in PMMC instruments can be produced by either spring control or gravity control.
• For spring control: Tc ∝ θ, and for gravity control: Tc ∝ sin θ 
• The damping torque in the PMMC instrument is provided by eddy current damping.
   

Advantages

• The PMMC has a high torque-to-weight ratio and, hence, has great accuracy.
• It produces no losses due to hysteresis.
• It has efficient damping characteristics and is not affected by a stray magnetic field.
   

Disadvantages

• Moving coil instruments are expensive.
• The moving coil instrument can only be used on the D.C. supply as the current reversal produces a torque on the coil.
• It may show an error due to the loss of magnetism of the permanent magnet.

Electrodynamometer instruments

• Electrodynamometer instruments are a type of measuring device used to measure both AC (alternating current) and DC (direct current) electrical quantities such as current, voltage, and power.
• Electrodynamometer-type wattmeters are widely used as standard reference instruments in laboratories because of their high accuracy and precision.
• They work on the principle of the interaction between the magnetic fields produced by fixed and moving coils.

Principle of Operation:

• Fixed coils produce a magnetic field. Moving coil interacts with the magnetic field of the fixed coils, resulting in a deflecting torque proportional to the product of the current in both coils.
• For current measurement: Both coils (fixed and moving) are connected in series to carry the same current. The torque generated is proportional to the square of the current, making the instrument respond to both AC and DC.
• For power measurement: One set of coils is connected in series with the load (to measure current), and the other set is connected across the load (to measure voltage). The deflecting torque in this case is proportional to the product of voltage, current, and the power factor, which allows it to measure true power in AC circuits.

Ammeter:

• It is used to measure the current.
• An ideal ammeter has zero internal resistance and thus it provides the path for maximum current.
• It is always connected in series as it measures current.
• The range of ammeter can be extended by using a low shunt resistance.

Voltmeter:

• It is used to measure the voltage.
• An ideal voltmeter has infinite resistance and thus it provides the path for minimum current.
• It is always connected in parallel as it measures voltage.
• The range of voltmeter can be extended by using a high series resistance.

The essential features are possessed by an indicating instrument deflecting, controlling, and a damping device.

• Deflecting device: The deflection device produces deflecting torque which causes the moving system to move from its zero position.
• Controlling device: The controlling device produces the controlling torque (Tc) which opposes the deflecting torque and increases with the deflection of the moving system. It also brings the pointer back to zero when the deflecting torque is removed.
• Damping device: This device produces damping torque this torque is necessary to bring the pointer to rest quickly. This damping torque (Td)  is used to reduce the oscillation.

Moving iron meter has large magnetic reluctance as compared to PMMC meter. That’s why more power is required to operate the moving iron meter.

Advantages of moving iron:

• It is a universal instrument which can be used for the measurement of AC and DC quantities
• These instruments can withstand large loads and are not damaged even under severe overload conditions
• It is very cheap due to the simple construction

Disadvantages of moving iron:

• These instruments suffer from error due to hysteresis, frequency change and stray losses
• The reading of the instrument is affected by temperature variation

Note: In terms of accuracy PMMC meter has the highest accuracy. The order of accuracy is given below.

Induction < Moving iron < PMMC instruments

Null type instrument: An instrument in which zero or null indication determines the magnitude of measured quantity, such type of instrument is called a null type instrument.

It uses a null detector which indicating the null condition when the measured quantity and the opposite quantity are same.

The permanent magnet moving coil (PMMC) instrument uses two permanent magnets to create a stationary magnetic field. These types of instruments are only used for measuring the DC quantities.

Electrolytic meters are exclusively DC ampere-hour meters, measuring an electric quantity directly and electric energy only indirectly, on the assumption that the pressure of the supply is constant.

Dynamometer type instrument is used for the measurement of A.C. as well as D.C. quantity. It is equally accurate on AC and DC circuits.

Shaded-pole type and induction type instruments are only used for AC measurements.

• The instruments which use the heating or thermal effect of the current for knowing their magnitude such type of instrument is known as the hot wire instrument.
• The hot wire instrument is used for both the AC and DC current.
• Hotwire instrument works on the principle of the thermal effect, that the length of the wire increases because of the heating effect of the current flow through it.
• When the current is passed through the fine platinum-iridium wire it gets heated up and expands.
• The sag of the wire is magnified, and the expansion is taken up by the spring.
• This expansion causes the pointer to deflect, indicating the value of the current.
• This expansion is directly proportional to the heating effect of the current and hence directly proportional to the square of the RMS value of the current.
• Therefore, the meter may be calibrated to read the rms value of the current.​

The permanent magnet moving coil instrument uses two permanent magnets to create a stationary magnetic field. These types of instruments are only used for measuring the DC quantities.

If we apply AC current to these types of instruments the direction of current will be reversed during the negative half cycle and hence the direction of torque will also be reversed which gives the average value of torque zero.

Important Points:

• Permanent Magnet Moving Coil (PMMC) is only used for DC measurements.
• Moving Iron (MI) type instruments can be used for both AC & DC measurements.
• Rectifier-type instruments are used for AC measurements.
• Induction-type instruments are only used for AC measurements.
• Thermocouple meters can be used for both DC as well as AC quantities.

Concept:

PMMC ammeters use spring controlling and deflecting torque varies directly as current

In spring control instrument, the controlling torque is given by,

\(Tc = {K_c}\theta\)

\({T_d} \propto I\)

In a PMMC instrument deflecting torque is directly proportional to current.

The final steady state deflection of PMMC instrument is directly proportional to current flowing through the coil.

At equilibrium position, TC = TD

⇒ I ∝ θ

• In case of over damping, the instrument will become slow and lethargic and it rises very slowly from its zero position to final position
• An over damped system would never allow the system to reach the desired end state since it is over damped and that is why they are never used.