Dividend Decision: Types, Key Factors, and Impact on Firm Value

The dividend decision seeks to strike a balance between an immediate return to shareholders and what the company earns for its continued growth. This will be affected by the profitability, liquidity, and growth opportunities of the company as well as conditions in the capital market-at best, a good dividend policy can signal health and future prospects to enhance shareholder value. The dividend is all about the earnings to pay out as dividends as compared to retaining the same by the firm and putting it again in the business to generate more profits. Navigating through the maze of financial management, one cannot ignore the importance of dividend decisions in a corporation's financial planning. By knowing the mechanics of these decisions, we can gain senses of corporate governance and investor relations. It applies selecting the proper dividend payout ratio and dividend per share. The decision is crucial as it impacts the wealth of shareholders and the cash available for the firm's growth plans.

Various such decisions are part of the UGC-NET Commerce Examination, and learners should learn about them in detail for the examination. UGC-NET Commerce syllabus is vast so the learners are advised not to skip important topics like this.

In this article, we will study the following:-

• What is a Dividend Decision?
• Importance of Dividend Decision
• Issues in Dividend Decisions
• Purpose of Dividend Decision
• Factors Affecting the Dividend Decision
• Advantages of Dividend Decision
• Disadvantages of Dividend Decision
• Example of Dividend Decision
• Theories of Dividend Decision
• Nature of Dividend Decision
• Objectives of Dividend Decision

Click Here to Download UGC NET Paper 1 Important Questions PDF

Read about banking sector reforms in India.

What is a Dividend Decision?

The meaning of the dividend decision can be learnt as the policy a firm adopts to decide how to allocate its net earnings among shareholders and internal reinvestment. This financial decision mainly deals with two major questions, as mentioned below.

• What proportion of the firm's earnings should be allocated to the shareholders as dividends?
• What portion of the earnings should be retained within the firm for reinvestment or to cover future contingencies?

Fig: dividend decision

Dividend decision concerns the most vital aspect of retaining or distributing the profit with reference to shareholders. It is also a means of satisfying investors, valuing the company, and market perception. The extent of dividend decisions can be learnt from the points mentioned below.

• Dividends therefore become the important part of shareholders' total return, as the amount and timing of dividends define cash being paid to shareholders.
• The future cash flows for shareholders, such as dividends and capital gains, determine the prices of shares. The dividend policy has direct implications for prices and returns.
• Regular and stable dividends reflect the capability and willingness of a firm to realize good conditions and healthy profits. This, in turn, earns investor confidence.
• Where personal cash flow is insufficient for the requirement of regular income by its shareholders, dividends are so viewed as important sources of finance. It has consequences on their income as well as cash flows.
• Builds Trust the Stakeholder. Regular Dividends Pave the Way for Investor Confidence.
• The Cost of Dividend Signals: Costs of Dividend Signal to Investors About a Company's Financial Condition.
• Retained Profits vs. Dividends: The decision weighs the necessity for growth of the firm (retained profits) and the need to satisfy shareholders (dividend payout).

Read about Foreign Banks.

Issues in Dividend Decisions

Short Run Dividend Decision involves several conflicts between the interest of different shareholders regarding the expectations for dividend returns and the financial sustainability and reinvestment needs that arise in such cases. Apart from these factors, companies also have to deal with legal restrictions, liquidity concerns, and tax considerations. Thus, the dividend decision-making process encompasses numerous complications.

• The dividend policy must be sustainable for the company in the long run. 
• Earnings Stability: Fluctuating earnings can create confusion around the dividend decision. 
• Growth Opportunities: A company with significant growth potentials may be adverse to distributing past profits considering the probable return from reinvestment. Thus, a dividend could be followed by transient earnings because the public often views dividends as a clue of how the company is performing. 
• Market expectations: Dividend decisions may be shaped by market expectations. The investor now deems this pair to be necessary to maintain a stable stock price.
• Dividend vs Retention: Higher dividends mean lower retention for reinvestment, while higher retention means lower dividends. A balanced approach is needed.
• Present vs Future: Current shareholders prefer higher current dividends, while the firm's long-term options may require higher retention.

Purpose of Dividend Decision

The primary purpose of the dividend decision is to determine the division of earnings between payouts to shareholders and reinvestment into the firm. The goal of the dividend decision can be known from the explanation below.

• Distribution of Profits: One of the primary goals of any business is to award its owners by sharing the profits earned. Dividends serve this purpose.
• Providing Liquidity to Shareholders: Regular dividends feed liquidity to shareholders and a means to earn a return on their investment.
• Maximizing Shareholder's Wealth: An optimal dividend policy which considers growth and return aspects can maximize the welfare of equity shareholders.

Read about the Capital market.

Factors Affecting The Dividend Decision

Several internal and external factors influence a firm’s dividend policy, including profitability, cash flow, growth prospects, and taxation. Understanding these factors helps in forming a rational and sustainable payout strategy. Several factors impact the dividend decision, as noted below.

• Legal Restrictions: Certain jurisdictions may limit the amount of dividends a firm can pay out.
• Liquidity: Companies must have sufficient cash resources to distribute dividends.
• Profitability: Companies which are more profitable tend to distribute higher dividends.
• Business Cycle: Dividend payments may be reduced by companies during downturns when cash conservation is considered a priority. 
• Earnings: Earnings levels and their stability play an important role in dividend decision. Both current and expected future earnings are taken into consideration.
• Cash balances: Availability of excess cash after all cash needs have been met determines the cash available for dividends.
• Finance needs: Funds required for short and long-term capital investments and working capital requirements, affect the decision. More financing needs imply lower dividends.
• The shareholder preference: Whether the need and taxation status of equity shareholders affect dividend policy determines that those in a higher tax bracket may opt for lower payout. 
• Legal provisions: Maximum payout ratios for different categories of companies and other provisions are made in the Companies Act. From these provisions, flexibility is limited in decision-making. 
• Age of the firm: Younger growth companies typically have low or no dividends. As companies mature, it is stability in earnings and higher payout ratios that are formed. 
• Current economic climate: Lower profits and higher uncertainty during recession imply lower dividends. While during prosperity, the converse holds good. Boards take the state of the economy into account.
• Tradition and historical records: Boards maintain stable and coherent histories of dividends paid over the years. Sudden or frequent changes in dividends are not welcomed and are avoided unless necessary. Past payout ratios are thought. 
• Contractual obligations: Rules and covenants in loan contracts regarding payment of dividends are generally taken into consideration while declaring any dividend. Some debt agencies outright prohibit dividends.

Read about financial services.

Advantages of Dividend Decision

A well-planned dividend policy enhances shareholder trust, signals financial strength, and provides regular income to investors. It also boosts the company’s reputation and can positively influence share prices. The advantages have been stated below.

• Wealth of Shareholders: The benefit is that making regular payments of dividends would substantially augment the wealth of a shareholder and even attract investors who seek incomes from investments. 
• Market Perception: Advantage: The objective consistency in dividend payouts would build a better market perception of the company being stable and also financially strong. 
• Tax Treatment: Advantage: Dividends in some jurisdictions are taxed lower than capital gains which make them attractive for many different investors. 
• Management Discipline: Dividends would force management to use funds economically and restrain them from spending these on investment projects that do not yield reasonable returns.
• Cash Flow Signals: Advantage: Dividend payments can serve as signals to the market regarding the company's confidence in its future cash flows and financial stability.

Also read about Risk and return analysis.

Disadvantages of Dividend Decision

Frequent or high dividend payouts can limit funds available for reinvestment and innovation. Additionally, inconsistent policies may signal instability and lead to investor uncertainty. The disadvantages of Dividend Decision have been stated below.

• Reduced Retained Earnings: Paying dividends reduces the amount of earnings retained by the company, which could otherwise be reinvested for growth or used to pay off debt.
• Market Misconception : A sudden modification in dividend policy or failure to make expected dividend payments can bring about a misinterpretation in the market for the effect of such negative factor on the stock price for that given company.
• Inflexibility: Once established, it is often difficult to deviate from a dividend payout pattern without raising anyone's eyebrows at the investors.
• Financial Constraints: If companies decide to declare high and stable dividends, their budgets will be so restricted that they will not be able to invest in new projects or adjust to adverse economic conditions.
• Preference of tax deferral gains: Some investors prefer capital gains rather than dividends since taxes may be deferred until the investment is sold. This could provide them with more favorable savings.
• Market Volatility: In times of market uncertainty or economic downturns, companies may be reluctant to maintain or increase dividend payments, which could disappoint income-focused investors.

Read about types of dividend decision.

Example of Dividend Decision

ABC Ltd earned profits after tax of INR 50 crore in the year 2019-20. The firm has growth plans for diversification and needs INR 25 crore. The firm traditionally pays 30-50% of its profits as dividends. Shareholders prefer stable and uniform returns over time.

Considering the various factors, the board announces a dividend of INR 15 per share on 10 crore shares resulting in a payout of INR 150 crore (30% of profits). Retained earnings of INR 25 crore would be used to fund the proposed growth plan. The decision attempts to strike a balance between shareholder needs, firm needs, and past trends.

Also, read about Financial Institutions.

Theories of Dividend Decisions 

Understanding the theories or key models of dividend decisions can be extremely useful during the UGC NET, MBA, and financial examinations as these models serve as a framework for analyzing whether dividends affect the value of a firm or not.

Modigliani and Miller (M&M) 

Proposition: Franco Modigliani & Merton Miller (1961) 

• Core idea: Dividend policy is irrelevant to determining the value of a firm in a perfect capital market. 

Assumptions

• No tax or transaction costs
• Perfect capital market- no asymmetries of information
• Rational investor 
• No flotation or issuance costs 
• Fixed investment policy

Implication: Under M&M, a firm value does depend, solely to its earnings, not by way of how these earnings are split between dividends and retention. Investors are indifferent by dividends and capital gains.

Walter’s Model (Dividend Relevance Theory)

• Proposed by: Prof. James E. Walter
• Core Idea: Dividend decisions are relevant, and the value of the firm depends on the relationship between return on investment (r) and the cost of capital (k).

Formula

P= D+(r/k)(E−D) / k

Where:

• P = Market price of share
• D = Dividend per share
• E = Earnings per share
• r = Rate of return on investment
• k = Cost of equity capital

Implication

• If r > k, firm should retain earnings (no dividend)
• If r < k, firm should distribute dividends
• If r = k, indifferent to dividend or retention

Gordon’s Growth Model (Bird-in-the-Hand Theory)

• Proposed by: Myron Gordon
• Core Idea: Investors prefer certain dividends today over uncertain capital gains in the future.

Formula

P= D1/ k−g

Where

• D1 = Expected dividend next year
• k = Cost of equity
• g = Growth rate of earnings

Assumptions

• Firm is an all-equity firm
• r and k are constant
• Retained earnings are the only source of finance
• No external financing

Implication

High dividends reduce investor risk and increase share price. Firms that pay more dividends are seen as less risky.

Residual Dividend Theory

Core Idea: Dividends should be paid only after all profitable investment opportunities are funded.

Approach

1. Determine optimal capital budget
2. Use retained earnings to finance investments
3. Pay any remaining (residual) profits as dividends

Implication

• Dividend payout fluctuates yearly
• Firm prioritizes investment over dividend
• Most useful in growth companies with high reinvestment needs

Comparison Table: Dividend Models

Understanding the distinction among major dividend decision models can help in understanding one's interpretation of the impact of dividends on a firm's value through each theory. The table below compares the most important models-Modigliani-Miller, Walter's, Gordon's, and the Residual Theory-on their main assumptions, relevance, and strategic insights. This would prove especially useful for UGC NET Commerce and MBA exam preparation.

Nature of Dividend Decision

The dividend decision is multi-faceted and strategic in nature. It is influenced by various factors and can have long-lasting impacts on a company's financial health and growth.

• Long-Term Consequence: This decision greatly influences the long-term financial plan of a corporation. A generous distribution might draw investors in the short run, but it might cease growth resources for the future; alternatively, a lower payout might fund the growth but annoy those wanting returns.
• Balancing: The fine balance which has to be struck between what dividend is paid to shareholders and what is retained as profits for development. It.ordinarily requires balancing the expectations of shareholders with those of a business over the long term. 
• Investor Signal. Dividend policy decisions usually pass off in the market as signals. On one side, it perceived, the dividend for regular and consistent would mean financial stability and profitability and that more investors would likely be attracted. On the other side, a sudden change in a dividend policy brings uncertainty. 
• Legal-Contractual Obligation. This is the law- that slows or might by the law demand total dividends with some jurisdictions defining the dividend while debt covenants may also prevent the company from disbursing dividends.
• Impact on Firm's Leverage: The decision can affect a company's debt-to-equity ratio. Higher retained earnings can reduce the firm's reliance on external financing, thus reducing financial risk.

Read about the foreign exchange management act fema.

Objectives of Dividend Decision

The primary objective of a dividend decision is to maximize shareholder wealth while maintaining financial flexibility. It aims to balance short-term returns with long-term company growth. There are several common goals that most companies aim to achieve:

• Payout and Retention Optimization: The main object is to achieve an optimal balance between dividends and retained earnings since dividends attract people but retained earnings are also necessary for making future growth possible and maintaining liquidity.
• Maximizing Shareholder Wealth: Companies are with the aim of maximizing farmers wealth. Regular and increasing dividends raise the share price of the company which is benefitted by the shareholders. However, well-planned reinvestment of retained earnings also leads to appreciation in long-run share price.
• Stable Dividend: Stability in dividends over time is often an objective as it has signaled financial health and stability. Frequent and drastic changes in dividends can shake investor confidence.
• Legal Compliance: Companies are supposed to comply with legal limitations over dividend payout. Therefore, legal compliance becomes one of the objectives.
• Financial sustainability: The dividend decision must also ensure financial sustainability of the firm; for example, overgenerous dividend policies damaging the long-term financial health of the firm are inadvisable.
• Signalling Intent: The dividend decision often acts as a signal to investors about the firm's current and future performance. A higher dividend may indicate strong current performance and positive future expectations.

Read about Commercial banks.

Conclusion

So crucial do the nuances of dividend decision-making become in one catalog of corporate finance. It is not merely a decision on profit sharing; it strategically affects the future growth and financial sustenance of the firm. An understanding of what dividend decisions are is thus the first step toward the understanding of corporate financial management's intricate workings. It is, hence, a series of strategic decisions with a plethora of factors in the balance that determine the shape of an organization's success in the future. In ensuring financial health and sustainable growth, a balance must be struck between the payment of dividends and the retention of earnings for reinvestment.

The concept of the dividend decision is an exciting business operations function. Pupils must design the same for several commerce exams. The Testbook App can help make such cases easy. 

Read about Factors limiting the insurability of risk.

Dividend Decision Previous Year Questions

Which of the following theories of dividend is based on the assumption of perfect capital markets and no taxes?

1. a) Walter’s Model
2. b) Gordon’s Model
3. c) Modigliani-Miller Hypothesis
4. d) Residual Theory of Dividend

Answer: c) Modigliani-Miller Hypothesis